Rewind or Replace? HV Motor Decisions for Saudi Plants

16.11.26 08:57 AM

In short: when a medium or high voltage motor fails, the choice is between a rewind that restores it and a new motor that may be more efficient and better suited to the duty. Age, cause of failure, core condition, efficiency and lead time decide it. BTGC makes that assessment at the WEG approved service center in Jubail and supplies new WEG MV and HV motors where replacement is the better answer.

WEG medium voltage electric motor

A 3 MW compressor motor or a 6.6 kV pump motor is not a catalogue item that can be swapped from stock. When one fails, the plant needs a decision within days: rewind it, or order a new one and run on a spare or a reduced rate until it arrives. The wrong decision costs either a second failure a year later, or months of lost capacity waiting for a motor that was not needed.

Start with the cause of failure

A rewind only makes sense if the cause is understood and removed. A winding that failed from age and thermal ageing after twenty-five years is a good rewind candidate. A winding that failed after three years from contamination, a cooling problem, voltage surges from a drive or repeated starts will fail again if it is rewound the same way. The teardown inspection, insulation tests and core loss test come before any decision.

FactorPoints to rewindPoints to replace
Stator coreCore loss test passes, no hot spotsCore damage or hot spots that need restacking
Rotor and shaftBars, rings and shaft soundBroken bars, cracked rings or shaft damage
Age and designModern design, parts availableObsolete design, no drawings or parts
EfficiencyDuty is light or intermittentContinuous duty where a higher-efficiency motor pays back
Lead timeRewind in weeksNew motor available within the outage plan
Duty changeSame duty as beforeNew speed, VFD operation or higher rating needed

What a good rewind includes

  • Full teardown, cleaning and inspection of stator, rotor, bearings and cooling circuits.

  • Core loss test before and after stripping the old winding.

  • New coils with Class F or H insulation, vacuum pressure impregnation (VPI) and oven cure.

  • Surge, insulation resistance, polarisation index and high-potential tests; dynamic balancing of the rotor.

  • Full no-load run test and a report the plant can file.

HV motor stator under rewind at the BTGC workshop in Jubail

When replacing is the better investment

Some motors should not be rewound. Old designs with poor efficiency on continuous duty, motors that keep failing because they are undersized for the duty, and motors moving to variable speed operation without inverter-rated insulation are better replaced. A new WEG medium or high voltage motor can be built to the existing footprint, shaft height and coupling so the base and alignment do not change, and it comes with insulation designed for VFD duty when needed. See the article on MV and HV induction motors to API 541.

WEG from BTGC

BTGC is the WEG partner in Saudi Arabia for medium and high voltage motors and MV drives, and runs the WEG approved service center in Jubail for rewinds, overhauls, balancing and testing. The service center works on motors of all makes, so one team can assess the failed motor and quote both options. See the Jubail service center and the electrical and power systems page.

Questions buyers ask

How long does an HV rewind take? Typically a few weeks depending on size and parts; BTGC gives a programme after the teardown inspection.

Can you rewind other brands? Yes. The service center works on motors of all makes.

Will a rewound motor keep its efficiency? A rewind done to the original design with a passed core loss test keeps efficiency close to the original; damaged cores or poor practices reduce it, which is why the core test matters.

Contact the BTGC power division

Email power@btc-ksa.com or call +966 13 856 0528. Branches: Dammam, Jubail and Yanbu. Request a quote.